| Winner | Winner's Score | Loser | Loser's Score | Course | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mike Payne | 0 | Travis Parnell | 0 | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 | |
| Mike Payne | -26 | Andrew Davidson | -24 | SCABLANDS | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 |
| Mike Payne | -25 | Mike Parsons | -21 | MISSOURI HILLS | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 |
| Mike Payne | -24 | Art DeVries | -23 | Anse Cocos | St. Cloud 2021 |
| Mike Payne | -25 | Todd Boyer | -21 | Anse Cocos | St. Cloud 2021 |
| Mike Payne | 0 | Patrick Bogart | 0 | Baja Ria | St. Cloud 2021 |
| Mike Payne | -26 | James Trudeau | -24 | Grand Teton | St. Cloud 2020 |
| Mike Payne | -1 | Daniel Kaliszewski | 0 | Coconut Beach | Orlando 2013 |
| Winner | Winner's Score | Loser | Loser's Score | Course | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scott Peterson | 0 | Mike Payne | 0 | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 | |
| Scott Peterson | 0 | Mike Payne | 0 | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 | |
| Travis Parnell | -27 | Mike Payne | -22 | MISSOURI HILLS | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 |
| John Thurston | -28 | Mike Payne | -26 | NIHON YORU | FLORIDA OPEN 2023 |
| Chisolm Woodson | -29 | Mike Payne | -24 | PETRA | FLORIDA OPEN 2023 |
| Mike Warnick | 0 | Mike Payne | 0 | Baja Ria | St. Cloud 2022 |
| Mike Griffin | 0 | Mike Payne | 0 | Baja Ria | St. Cloud 2022 |
| Daniel Kaliszewski | -24 | Mike Payne | -18 | Tropical Falls | St. Cloud 2021 |
| Steve Puff | 0 | Mike Payne | 0 | Baja Ria | St. Cloud 2021 |
| Rob Holtrey | -23 | Mike Payne | -22 | Jamaica Bay | St. Cloud 2020 |
| Score | GSP | Course | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| -29 | 32302 | SOUTH PACIFIC | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 |
| -26 | 7708 | SCABLANDS | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 |
| -20 | 8179 | MANHATTAN VIEW | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 |
| -25 | 16596 | MISSOURI HILLS | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 |
| -25 | 0 | BONNIE MOOR BLACK | FLORIDA OPEN 2024 |
| -28 | 29592 | EASTER ISLAND | FLORIDA OPEN 2023 |
| -20 | 0 | NORDDALEN | FLORIDA OPEN 2023 |
| -22 | 0 | HOLLYWOOD HILLS | FLORIDA OPEN 2023 |
| -23 | 14869 | CHAMP 99 | FLORIDA OPEN 2023 |
| -25 | 8003 | NIHON YORU | FLORIDA OPEN 2023 |